A Lesson on Locking in Losses: Remember Buy Low and Sell High (or Never)...

-
US REIT Index Fund-FSRVX 1 Year Performance


Towards the end of January I decided to rid myself of my REIT index fund, FSRVX, and exchange half of it for an Emerging Market Fund, FPMIX, and a Total International Market Fund, FSGDX.  At the time I rationalized that I had very little international exposure in my portfolio and I was tired of my REIT fund’s under performance-I believe it was down around 6% at the time I sold.  If I’m honest, I was probably chasing last year’s outstanding returns for international funds. The financial news media’s chatter about Amazon being the death of the American Mall, and thus Retail REITs, finally caused me to give in.  And of course, six months later my Emerging Market fund is down -7.7% YTD, my Total International Fund is down -4.8%, and the REIT I sold is up 1.2%.  So you see-I sold my REIT when it was down, locking in losses, and bought two international funds just as they were about to lose value.  

Emerging Market Index Fund - FPMIX 1 Year Performance

Total International Market Index Fund - FSGDX 1 Year Performance

Learn from my mistake-buying high and selling low is always a losing proposition.  Thankfully I’m pretty diversified in other assets that have helped to counter my mistake-my NASDAQ and small cap funds are doing pretty well YTD.

Investment Rules:
  1. Buy and Hold-I should have kept my REIT fund and put new money into emerging markets
  2. Never sell an underperforming, widely diversified index fund-eventually the market recovers and you just locked in your losses by selling.
  3. I could have bought the underperforming fund-buy low, high-buy when the market is on sale
  4. Never chase last year’s performance-I bought the international funds just after a huge run-up last year.  They'll eventually recover so I won’t compound my mistake by selling them at a loss-I’ll keep buying more shares now that they're discounted.



Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Million Dollar 401k – Who Wants to Be a Millionaire?

-
Image
Every few months the financial press releases an article on the increasing number of 401k millionaires.“Number of 401k Millionaires reaches all time high”“41% increase in number of million dollar 401k accounts”.  The standard advice is offered on achieving this milestone-401k millionaires stay at the same job for years, are high earners, save enough to get a company match-in fact up to 15% of their earnings, and start saving at an early age.Easy right? Of course the ~150,000 401k millionaires at Fidelity represent less than 1% of their total number of retirement accounts.If it’s so easy why is the average American’s retirement savings only $95k?
The average salary in the United States is $56,000 before taxes.Federal taxes drop that number down another 20% (assuming you live in a no state income tax state). After housing-$12,000 rent, transportation $9,000, food $6,000, health care $4,000, and miscellaneous expenses $5-$10,000 there’s not much left for retirement savings.Add in the un…
Read more

The Power of Compounding Interest and Time on Investment Returns

-
Image
Compounding Interest is interest (return) that builds on prior period interest.  Say you invest $1000 in an asset that compounds 10% annually.  This is how your investment grows overtime:
Rate of Return: 10% Annually Initial Investment: $1000
Year 1: $1,000    +   $100       = $1,100Year 2: $1,100    +   $110       = $1,210Year 3: $1,210    +   $121       = $1,331Year 4: $1,331    +   $133.1    = $1464.1Year 5: $1464.1  +   $146.41  = $1610.51

Notice how the annual gains increase overtime?  That’s compounding interest-money going to work to make more money.  This is why it is important to begin saving for retirement as early as possible so that the power of compounding has time to work its magic on your savings.  This is also why it’s important to pay down high interest credit cards-if you’re paying the minimum on a credit card charging 15% of interest over time you can end up paying several times more for that handbag or television than the initial purchase price.  Worse, money you’r…
Read more

Index Fund Investing Research

-
Image
Conducting Research

To research Fidelity’s S&P 500 Index Fund (Ticker: FUSEX), or another provider's, look it up on your brokerage's website (see notes on navigating to Fidelity's investment products below).



The key item I look for in any index fund are the fees or expense ratio.  FUSEX has an expense ratio of 0.09% meaning that this fund will charge 90 cents per year for every $1000 invested in management fees to own this fund.  Also evaluate how well funds track their underlying index over time referred to as tracking error.  Some providers will report this directly but if yours does not you can head over to Google Finance and plot your fund versus its benchmark overtime.  In the example below, Fidelity’s Russell 2000 Index Fund (Ticker: FSSVX) is plotted against the Russell 2000 Index (Ticker: RUT).  You can see FSSVX tracks its benchmark within reasonable error-there’s a pretty steady delta over time.  Note: over long periods the difference will be largely due to t…
Read more